The perfect scuba diving bag doesn’t exist?

#neverwithoutmygear

It took me only a year after my open water certification to understand how much I hated renting scuba diving gear in dive centres: never the right size, questionable maintenance, bad habits of other scuba divers (you know what I’m talking about), you name it. Before I went on my first big scuba diving adventure of 5 weeks around Mexico, Guatemala and Belize, I made the decision to invest in my own gear and my first proper scuba diving bag with always having in mind to make it lighter, more compact and efficient. From that trip, I learnt what was critical for a good scuba diving when you are an independent traveller.

For more tips about travelling with scuba diving gear, don’t forget to read these blog posts which are some of my most read articles:

The specifications of the perfect scuba diving bag

scuba diving bag - Early start for an express diving trip to Italy

I popped up the question with a poll in the World Adventure Divers’ Facebook group “what would you like to ask bag manufacturers?” Here is the ranking of the most critical specifications with some comments I gathered from everyone and some from my experience.

  1. Lightweight: Below 3,5 kg seems to be the ideal weight. The idea is that the bag itself shouldn’t “eat” the luggage allowance on flights.
  2. Robust wheels: The wheels are usually one of the biggest weaknesses among scuba diving bags, but not having them considering the weight of the gear is not optional. They need to be robust and be able to handle a weight of 30kg. Being able to change them as they often break before the bag even starts to show some fatigue signs would be awesome.
  3. Case for clothes: Having a dry space where we can put our clothes is definitely a must. Personally, I use packing cubes at the moment, which I love, but it is always better to have a separate pocket for clothes.
  4. Backpack: I found myself in countless situations such as having to cross a country border on foot, walking to the dive centre on the beach which means sand, train stations with only stairs available, etc. where you absolutely need to put the bag on your back. The only exception would be road trips.
  5. Saltwater resistant zip: Having a zip crust up and stuck is very unpleasant when you either can’t get stuff out of the bag or when you find that you can no longer zip the bag closed before flying back home.
  6. Storage for small items: With all the electronics we are carrying, a dedicated (mesh) pocket for chargers and cables would be much appreciated. An excellent extra feature would be a cushioned compartment for more fragile equipment such as torches or regulators.
  7. Not too small, not too big: Except when travelling with a drysuit, 90 to 120L is not necessary anymore when you have light and compact travel diving gear. The right ratio would be between 60 to 80L because a 40/50L bag is a bit short for longer travels except maybe if you are in a warm country where you only need a few t-shirts and shorts
  8. Toughness: The materials used must be as tough as possible without impacting too much the weight of the bag. Ideally, the bag needs to handle 25,000 km of travel without any scratch.
  9. Dimensions: Not too high when worn as a backpack and not too wide so you can roll it between seats in a train, but the most important of all is to fit airlines’ restrictions for checked-in luggage. For example, British Airways ask for a maximum of 90 x 75 x 43cm (35.5″x29.5″x16″) while Air France asks the sum of the dimensions (height+width+depth) not to exceed 158 cm! So always double check the restrictions on your favourite airlines.
  10. Waterproof:  the entire bag doesn’t need to be waterproof but having to pack a wet wetsuit is not rare at all, so even a separate waterproof bag is a minimum feature.
  11. Other: Robust and comfortable handles, solid zipper pulls that won’t break too fast, no “steal me” label (famous brands printed in big, bright colours or scuba diving flags)

 

Reviews of the 5 bags I used in 8 years of diving trips

An important thing I realise is not every scuba diver needs the same bag and even sometimes, depending on the type of diving trips we do, we don’t always need the same either. Do you travel to warm or cold countries? Will you bring a drysuit? Is it a road trip or will you take public transportation? Through my experience of backpacking or road tripping with scuba diving gear with 5 different bags, I hope you can get a better idea of what YOU need, and the necessary specifications to look at when you buy your next scuba diving bag!

  • Decathlon Tribord 120L / not available anymore

Travelled 28,585 km without flights from 2010 to 2014 to Mexico / Guatemala / Belize / France / Spain / Indonesia / Turkey / Thailand / Argentina / India / Italy

Strengths:  I could put everything in its separate pockets: my full diving equipment, my clothes and all I need for more than a month of travelling. My greatest achievement with this bag has been for my trip to Argentina. In a bag of 20kg, I could take suitable clothing for Iguazu (tropical climate) to Ushuaia (polar climate), my hiking gear, my BCD, my mask and my fins. Inside the main volume, it had many small mesh pockets to put all the small equipment.

Weaknesses: The wheels broke when I moved to Scotland, but given the number of km I travelled with this bag it’s kind of okay but it’s really frustrating because almost everything else is in good condition. The zipper pulls broke quickly (so annoying). The bag was too tall for me when I was carrying it as a backpack. Because of its height, the designers maybe thought it was ok not to have a telescopic handle, but I must say it was tiring to roll it especially since the foam of the handle crushed very quickly. The separate waterproof bag was a great idea except it’s not really waterproof.

weight 4,2 kg (9.3lbs) storage for small items yes
wheels yes internal volume 120 L
case for my clothes yes toughness high
backpack yes dimensions 89 x 43 x 30 cm (35″x17″x12″)
saltwater resistant yes waterproof no
  • Airtex Atlas 46Lstill available

Travelled 2,856 km without flights from 2014 to 2017 to Switzerland / The Phillippines / Honduras

Strengths: To be honest, I first bought this bag to travel incognito with scuba diving gear when I was on a business trip(!). I realised later that it was a significant advantage not to have a bag screaming “I have expensive gear inside!” On its first trip, I managed to cram all my snow equipment into it: my boots, my BCD, my mask and my fins to go ice diving in Switzerland. When travelling to tropical destinations, it is a bit easier to gain weight and volume thanks to light clothing and a wetsuit, so I took it to the Philippines for 1 month and to Honduras for 2 weeks. The fact I could put my diving equipment separately from my clothes was perfect.

Weaknesses: I have to admit it wasn’t that easy to put everything inside. Even if I found the perfect order to combine all my gear inside and used my packing cubes for my clothes, every time I had to sit on the suitcase to close the zips! The material inside the bag is clearly not made for such stress, and it has already started to tear off. I only made a few trips so I will have to be careful if I want to keep it.

weight 3,1 kg (6.83lbs) storage for small items yes
wheels yes internal volume 46 L
case for my clothes yes toughness medium
backpack yes dimensions 65 x 39 x 18 cm (26″x15″x7″)
saltwater resistant no waterproof no
  • Aqua Lung T8 Roller Duffle Backpack 92L / not available anymore

Travelled 21,295 km without flights from 2015 to 2017 to Iceland / Indonesia / Florida / France / Malta / Canary Islands / Belgium / The Netherlands / Italy / Japan / Croatia / Switzerland / Greece / Hawaii

Strengths: Very light and a lot of space inside this bag of 92L, perfect to travel with a drysuit and its undersuit. I travelled to Iceland and Japan with everything for cold water diving with only 16 kg. I love its telescopic handle. It is so comfortable, I am much less tired when I roll the bag than with the Tribord bag. The backpack system is super quick to pull out when you just need to climb some stairs.

Weaknesses: There are no separate pockets for clothes or anything else at all. So I bought my mesh packing cubes, but when my gear is still a bit wet, they can’t keep my clothes dry. The comfort of the backpack system could be a bit improved but as I’m carrying my bag on my back only for short periods, it is kind of fine. Unfortunately, one of the corners is starting to tear off, the designers should have put more protections around them especially the corners that touch the ground when the bag is standing vertically. Once again, considering the distance I did with this bag, it is not too bad.

weight 3,95 kg (8.71lbs) storage for small items no
wheels yes internal volume medium
backpack yes dimensions 79 x 33 x 33 cm (31″x14″x13″)
saltwater resistant yes waterproof no
  • Aqua Lung Defense Dry Duffel 85L / still available

Travelled 4,251 km from 2014 to 2016 all around Scotland, from St Abbs to Scapa Flow via the Sound of Mull.

Strengths: The Aqua Lung Dry Duffel is perfectly waterproof either from the inside or outside, this is the most robust material I’ve ever seen, and I have really not been kind to it during my two years in Scotland. Big internal space where you can throw anything you like. I really like the little sketch behind the flap with the scuba diver equipment checklist!

Weaknesses: If it’s the perfect bag for road trips, I don’t recommend it at all to go backpacking as it’s not easy at all to carry it on the shoulder. I also found the plastic purge not practical when you need to remove water from the bag, so I disassembled it every time I was washing the bag!

weight 1,25 kg (2.75lbs) storage for small items no
wheels no internal volume 85 L
case for my clothes no toughness high
backpack no dimensions 66 x Ø41cm (26’xØ16′)
saltwater resistant yes waterproof yes
  • Aqua Lung Explorer Carry-On 45Lstill available

The Aqua Lung Explorer carry-on is my latest acquisition, so I only used it once on a Paris-Toulon scuba diving weekend. As I have now left my old drysuit in residence in Toulon, I just need to carry less gear! It was a good first trial where I could prove I could easily put all my gear including fins (the sides have been specially designed for the hot-shot fins), mask, regulator, undersuit, and clothes for the weekend. I’m excited to soon use it on a weekend getaway in South Europe, without having to pay for checked-in luggage on low-cost airlines. The only problem is I need to wait for the right season, usually from July, so the water is warm enough to dive in a wetsuit!

weight 3,0 kg (6.75lbs) storage for small items yes
wheels yes internal volume 45 L
case for my clothes no toughness high
backpack no dimensions 56 x 35 x 23 cm  (22″x14″x9″)
saltwater resistant yes waterproof no

Window shopping for my next big adventure

As I’m currently preparing a new big adventure for the second half of 2018, I started to look for my next best companion. At Paris Dive Show in January, I was disappointed to see there was no good in-between for me. It’s either you have to choose between large roller bags without any backpack system (I guess if you’re only doing liveaboard that’s fine) or some small waterproof backpacks without any wheels. I was first really attracted to these waterproof backpacks, and there was quite an interesting choice of them with many brands offering them.

The Apex Dry 75 bag seems perfect regarding size and toughness, you can even attach the smaller Apex Dry 12 bag to it. The only problem for me is, as a blogger who travels with a laptop and underwater photography gear, I now need my Riut 25 backpack to securely pack these as my cabin carry-on. So when I’m wearing it, it’s just easier to roll the scuba diving gear bag behind me. Occasionally, when I have obstacles to cross, I put my scuba diving bag on my back and the small backpack in front of me. OK, so I need to look further…

2 weeks later, I gave a try to one of the most famous outdoors stores in Paris, to look for travel bags that could do the trick. For sure, I would lose the saltwater resistant materials but regular outdoors brands may have some good ideas too. I quickly found two rolling backpacks that seem interesting with the perfect volume I’m looking for: the Osprey Sojourn 60 R (60L) and the Eagle Creek Expanse Conv 29 (78L).

The Osprey was quite light (3,87kg) and has high-quality materials and pockets for small items. Unfortunately, I found the backpack system too long to set up for the occasional use I have of it. Although it is very comfy, I think it is too luxurious for what I need. Regarding the Eagle Creek, it has a sleeker design and a bigger internal volume but for almost the same height than the Osprey. The two things I didn’t like were the hip belt that was way to low on my hips and hence very uncomfortable, and the bottom corners are not well protected, so I know that they will get damaged quickly. I liked the Osprey more, but unfortunately, it is 3 times the cost of my usual scuba diving bags so I will think about it.

So what should I do? Should I “finish” my Aqua Lung Duffle bag or maybe buy the 63L version of my Airtex hybrid suitcase? Hmmh…

If you are a travel/watersport/outdoors bag manufacturer and you are reading this, will you take up the challenge of designing the perfect scuba diving bag?  If you think you can, don’t hesitate to contact me!

 

 

If you enjoyed this post, subscribe to WAD Newsletter to receive the latest posts and all the behind the scenes stories once a month (100% guaranteed spam-free) 

This article contains affiliate links. It means that if you decide to buy something, I will receive a small commission at absolutely no extra cost to you. If you like World Adventure Divers, thank you for supporting my work! 🙂


PIN IT FOR LATER

the perfect scuba diving bag doesn't exist?the perfect scuba diving bag doesn't exist?

  1. Totally understand with your disappointment. We use a regular suitcase for our dive gears because there are no scuba diving bag/suitcase that can fit two scuba divers’ gears plus my photography gears 😀 But I own osprey travel bag and loving it! Great post, Florine!

    Reply

    1. thank you so much Indah! Which Osprey bag do you have?

      Reply

      1. Osprey Fairview 40 liter. I use it as my camera gear bag for the cabin. I think I will buy bigger one later on – it’s a very sturdy bag and light too..

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

w

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: