After hundreds of dives all around the world, I thought I was cursed. The first time I could have seen it was in Gili Trawangan, Indonesia, 5 years ago. The whale shark was below the boat at the safety stop, but I had ascended way before everyone else as my buddy had emptied his tank in only 20 minutes! A year later, I went back to Koh Tao for my divemaster at a time when it’s supposed to be an excellent season to spot whale sharks. After one full month diving around Koh Tao every single day, no whale shark. Another year after, touring in the Visayas, Philippines, I heard there was a place you could easily see whale sharks near Cebu. Unfortunately, it was a feeding tourist attraction, and I found on the internet pictures of people riding whale sharks… I decided I didn’t want to be part of that.
As a result, for the 8 years, I’ve been a scuba diver, I’ve been dying to see a whale shark. You could ask why it is so important to me? I have indeed been already blessed by many underwater wonders, whether diving with sea lions in Patagonia, manta rays in Komodo, dolphins in Belize, basking sharks in Scotland and finally mola-molas in Bali. So why the whale shark? Is it because it’s the biggest fish in the world? I don’t think so. Is it because of its beautiful white spotted blue-grey colours? Yes, maybe, aren’t they cute? Is it then because of their gracious and peaceful behaviour embodies why we need to protect the oceans? That might be the real reason! I wanted to witness how do they feel near us. Are they scared of us? Curious? Playful? I tried to find out.
Last winter, I watched “Finding Dory” with its new whale shark character “Hope”. I almost cried as it reminded me how bad I was hoping to see one! Just before going to Honduras, which was my ultimate plan, the friend who watched the movie with me made me a lucky charm gift: the plush toy of Hope! This is precisely what I needed before boarding my plane in the direction of Central America to go diving in Utila… Hope.
The best places in the world to swim with whale sharks
Knowing I wanted to see some whale sharks, I quickly listed the places I had the best chances to see them. Unfortunately, most of the sites were too expensive, too, far away. If like me you badly want to see whale sharks, here are a few places to consider:
- Galapagos, Equator: The best time is between June and December. For higher chances, you need to board liveaboards in the direction of the remote Wolf and Darwin Islands, which roughly start from 5,000$.
- Ningaloo Reef, Australia: The whale shark season is from March to June but peak season would be in May. Any diving activity in Australia is known for not being budget travellers friendly. It’s quite a trip to get there as first you need to fly to Australia and then travel to this remote place on the West coast of Australia, 1130 km north of Perth.
- Tofo, Mozambique: The best period is between June and January. If you thought because it’s Africa it would be cheap, you need to know safari tourism is a luxury thing all along the Eastern African Coast, prepare your dollars!
- Holbox, Mexico: Book in July/August for the peak season. It might be the most affordable option on this list with the best chance to see them, but you need to spend about 200$ to snorkel with them and many, many other people.
On the other side, there are also a few whale sharks destinations that are more budget-friendly:
- Koh Tao, Thailand: Although I did my open water, advanced open water and divemaster training in Koh Tao, with 3 trips and 2 months spent there in total, I never got to see a whale shark there. However, let’s say I’ve been unlucky, because my friends living there see them regularly, often around Chumphon Pinnacle or Sail Rock. The best period is supposed to be from March to May and September to October, but you can see them all year long if you’re lucky. Koh Tao is famous for being one of the cheapest places in the world to get your open water; hence, it has become a scuba diving school island trendy among backpackers on the banana pancake trail.
- Donsol Bay, Philippines: For a chance to see wild whales sharks in the Philippines head to Donsol from February to April which is the peak season. The activity is very regulated; you can only snorkel with the whale sharks. Unfortunately, Donsol was a bit far away from my route on my first trip to the Visayas around Cebu. The best would be if you are travelling around Manilla area, by road it’s 535 km away, or you can take a 1-hour flight to Legazpi Airport. Generally speaking, The Philippines is an excellent destination for adventurous backpackers. Scuba diving can be cheap if you have your entire scuba diving gear with you. However, you need to travel for some time in the country to make a stop in Donsol worthy.
- Utila, Honduras: Utila is the Koh Tao of Central America. While Europeans and Australians head to Thailand to enjoy cheap diving rates, American and Canadian divers have the luck to have direct flights to Honduras. The reputation of Utila with whale sharks sighting was excellent. As I wanted to go back to Central America after my trip to Mexico/Guatemala/Belize, 7 years ago, I decided to make Utila my next target where I would have the best chance to break the curse without ruining myself. Besides, I hadn’t travelled for a while to a Spanish-speaking country. The excuse was perfect. I just waited to have the opportunity to be able to go between March and April. Another good season is supposed to be between September and December, but it seems you can spot them all year-long making Utila a whale shark hotspot.
Special note: This list cannot be exhaustive. However, for information, I removed on purpose from this list any destination I considered unethical.
Climate change is messing up whale shark seasons
On my first scuba diving day in Utila, the question was on my lips the whole time. I finally dared to pop up the question: “So… Have you seen any whale shark recently?” The answer was not what I was expecting. There had not been any sight in a while. Instead of just feeling devastated by the news, I decided to do some research. Even if I understand with nature, there is never any guarantee, if March/April is supposed to be the peak season, what was going on?
The first free afternoon I had, I decided to head to the WSORC in Utila. The Whale Shark & Oceanic Research Center has been researching since 1997 about the population of whale sharks swimming around Utila. In the beginning, they had simple tools such as handwritten tags that were inefficient, but as they got more funds, mainly through the volunteers joining for a few months or the tourists joining one of their snorkelling tours, they got a better and better system to understand more what bring whale sharks all year-long around Utila. The second goal of their research is also to monitor if the number of whale sharks visiting Utila is increasing or decreasing and how the local community can reduce its impacts on whale sharks while continuing to benefit from their presence.
While nobody exactly knows what the exact migration patterns of whale sharks are, DNA sample studies have proved there are different groups swimming in different areas. Whale sharks wouldn’t travel across oceans, but even this fact is not 100% sure. Then when we meet whale sharks underwater, they would be different groups in the Caribbean, South East Asia, the Indian Ocean or the Pacific Ocean.
One thing WSORC told me they were pretty sure is that the peak seasons (March/April or September/October) that used to repeat in the past seem to be all messed up by climate change. The observations showed that the whales sharks like warm and quiet seas.
This year in Honduras, February was way warmer than usual; it is supposed to be the rainy “winter”. Yet, in February 2017, they said during 2 weeks, they saw up to 5 whale sharks in a day, which is a record they got 5 years ago! I dared to ask “Does it mean what was supposed to happen in March/April occurred in February?” Rafael Monrique, Community Outreach Officer of WSORC, answered: “Could be, but you need to know that it is usually after a long quiet moment that suddenly we start to see a lot of whale sharks at once“. He gave me a bit more hope. I decided not to dream too much to avoid disappointment.
How I finally swam with 2 whale sharks in Utila
On my second diving day, during our surface interval, I had just laid down in the sun for precisely 30 seconds when the captain announced he was pretty sure he saw something. How to spot a whale shark from the surface? It seems whenever you see seagulls plunging and fish jumping at the surface, it means fish frenzy below which could mean whale sharks are in the area.
As we all executed the instructions to be ready in no time with our fins, mask and snorkel on, Mary from UDC shouted to everyone “Remember, don’t touch the whale shark!”. We were fully ready. I could almost not believe it. Was I about to finally see one? We waited. I waited. After 20 minutes of looking for whale sharks, we aborted the search. It was a false alarm, or we couldn’t find them said the captain trying to cheer everyone up. Still, I wanted to remain positive and thought at least the captain did his best. I said to myself “Who knows about tomorrow?”
On my third diving day, I changed my schedule and decided to join in the morning the members of the Eco Program of Utila Dive Center for a nature hike with the Conservation NGO Kanahau. After 4 hours hiking up and down, all across Utila, I made it just in time to catch the afternoon boat. When I arrived, directly our dive guide, Mary, asked “Have you heard? It’s confirmed, there have been whale sharks sightings. We go look for them before our dives, hurry up!” My heart pondered.
Everyone got ready as fast as they could. To save time, I decided only to put my rashguard on top of my swimsuit to avoid the gymnastics of putting my full 5mm wetsuit on. Anyway, water at the surface was 28°C, and we were meant to swim. It was a perfect choice, light but protected from the sun. I managed to secure a place at the front to be among the first ones who would get in the water.
We waited, fully equipped, and cameras in our hands. A religious silence prevailed on the boat. I think every single scuba diver on board was waiting for its whale shark dream to become true. Then the captain and Mary confirmed a whale shark was in sight. I had almost tears in my eyes due to the excitement. We crossed another boat during our approach; they indicated there were two whale sharks!
Because whale sharks are not as slow as you might think, we had to carefully follow the indications before sliding into the water as gently as possible to not scare the whale sharks away. “Go!!!”: we did it 7 times.
Each time we were going back to the boat to get another chance to see the whale sharks a bit further away. They are such beautiful and gentle animals. Our group of 10 divers was maybe still a bit too much action for them. Each time they checked us out but swam deeper away after 10/15 seconds. I have the answer to my question: they are curious but shy, at least in Utila. Knowing a whale shark can measure up to 13 m, I would say these two whale sharks were not that big, maybe 6 m maximum.
After sharing my video on my Facebook page, someone in Utila indicated that the first whale shark which has its caudal fin cut was famous and nicknamed “Old Tom”. After all these adventures, after all these emotions, can you imagine how happy, moved and thankful I was? If like me you’re dying to see a whale shark, take a chance and go to Utila!
On which boat should you jump on to see whale sharks?
I was scuba diving for 3 days with Utila Dive Center during my 4 days stay in Utila. I heard before my trip to Honduras you had higher chances to see the whale sharks in the blue and not on dive sites. Early on my arrival, I asked how to have such an opportunity to look for whale sharks. They explained that on any day they would try to find them and make time to snorkel with them if sightings are confirmed.
Something important to note is the extra fee to pay directly to the captain if he finds dolphins or whale sharks, and you decided to swim with them. It was only 200 Lempiras (about 9$, 8€ or £7) for dolphins and 300 Lempiras (about 13$, 12€ or £10) for whale sharks. Seriously, compared to the 200$ for the whale shark snorkelling trip in Mexico I thought that was a good tip for the captain’s efforts to make us all delighted! And if you think about it, thanks to the incentive it represents, you are sure the captain will do his best every single day to spot dolphins or whale sharks!
Utila Dive Centre has two boats: The smallest one “Old Tom” has the same name as the famous whale shark I saw first; the biggest one “Tristan” is the one I was on when we saw the two whale sharks. Depending on how your superstition works, I let you choose which one you prefer! (note: “Tristan” is exclusively used for scuba diving courses in the morning at the moment).
Do you want to learn more about travelling and scuba diving in Honduras? Have a look at the following articles:
If you enjoyed this post, subscribe to WAD Newsletter to receive the latest posts directly into your inbox.
PIN IT FOR LATER
Your so lucky Florine! in 12 months of working at UDC I only had 2 Whale Shark experiences although my colleagues had many many more – I just seemed to be unlucky! Hope you had a great time in Utila and loved reading the post!
It seems I had the same experience than you when I was doing my DMT in Koh Tao.. and now they seem to see them all the time over there too! ^^
Great post! My partner did this a few years back in an aquarium. The Stingrays gave birth whilst he was in there, sending the sharks into a frenzy. I must write about it some time. Good luck with your adventures.
wow, you saw stingrays giving birth!!!
Why didn’t just go to Isla Mujeres in Mexico? That’s the most concentrated whale shark colony in the world? You could have saved a FORTUNE as well. sheesh Talk about airfare! I took my nine year old son last summer and we spent hours swimming amongst huge whale sharks and enormous manta rays! And it only cost us a couple hundred bucks…
Hi Billy, my answer is in the article. Honduras is cheaper than Mexico and unfortunately, the experience in Mexico is far from being sustainable and respectful enough of the whale sharks.
Hey! Where can I find info on centers in Utila monitoring whale sharks? I am interested in a possible trip there in Jan 2020 and wanted to see what my chances are of catching these creatures. Thanks!
Hi Elsa, as explained in this blog post, January is not in the peak season even if you can virtually see whale sharks all year long in Utila. You can still try to contact WSORC!